Corruption is in the news A Massachusetts state senator recently was forced to resign after being accused of publicly groping several women. State Representative Diane Wilkerson had to resign after she was photographed accepting money for procuring a liquor license. The Speaker of the House is under heavy suspicion of corrupt practices. One of our local state representatives almost lost his recent reelection to a last-minute challenger because of personal conduct and financial transactions that appeared corrupt to many voters.
These are merely some examples of political corruption in Massachusetts and in Worcester. I do not have space to document pervasive corruption across the nation.
We have become accustomed to widespread public dishonesty but now a national survey shows that significant numbers of young people steal and lie. Dishonesty is no longer limited to business transactions or to politics. "In the past year, 30% of US high school students have stolen from a store and 64% had cheated on a test according to a new, large-scale survey..." Have you talked to your son or daughter about dishonesty lately?
Widespread dishonesty among young people is no doubt encouraged by the blatant corruption of our elected officials and the pervasive dishonesty in business that has brought our economy to the brink of collapse. If our political leaders as well as the business people who are "successful" -- who drive BMW’s up to their trophy homes -- get ahead by cutting corners, our young people will, of course, do the same.
Our nation does not only face the possibility of economic collapse; much more seriously, we are losing our moral standards. We are becoming a nation of liars, of thieves and petty chiselers.
What has happened to us?
Morality is anchored in personal relations. Lying to or stealing from persons you know seriously affects relationships. If your neighbors no longer trust you, your life loses security and comfort. If the people in your neighborhood think of you as untrustworthy, your place in the community changes for the worse. Dishonesty within the family creates serious problems.
But, in our world, we have fewer and fewer relationships within our immediate locality. Shoplifters do not steal from the local store whose owner may be a neighbor. They steal from an international corporation with stores not only in the US but all over the globe. The employer you lie to about being sick when you take a day off to do your Christmas shopping may have its headquarters in some foreign country. The businesses we may be tempted to steal from -- the drugstore or the insurance company – are vast international corporate giants. Your relationship to your employer is similarly impersonal. You have no personal relationship to the people you work for. You are not working for any human being but for an impersonal bureaucracy designed to put money in the pockets of its stockholders.
The government has, similarly, become large, impersonal, and distant. Local programs in Worcester are largely financed by the state of Massachusetts and the income tax it collects, as well as by the federal government and the taxes it takes from us. The city has little money of its own and little say-so over what happens here. Like businesses, the government has moved away and is no longer under our control. We may know some city politicians but they have very limited powers. Al they control is fixing roads and sidewalks.
Personal integrity has shrunk because it matters only in very limited contexts. It matters within the family, it matters with your friends. Many people in cities do not know their neighbors; many do not know their children's teachers. With a few exceptions we do not know who owns the local stores. The sales people we deal with, come and go.
Improved transportation has made a lot of difference. People move everywhere and rarely die anywhere either the place where they were born. A few years ago my neighbor died in her 80s in the house in which she was born. There are not many people like that left in America. Most of us are from “somewhere else.” Frequent moves disrupt personal connections between neighbors.
It is not enough to bemoan how footloose we have become and how impersonal life in our cities is today. Within limits, we can make efforts to know our neighbors, to engage in community improvement projects, to know who lives near us and to establish personal relations with them. Some neighborhoods managed to organize themselves to try to deal with local problems, to organize a crime watch, to build a park or playground. Most neighborhoods no longer do that. We do not know the people living close to us.
Efforts to maintain human relations in one's community are one way of maintaining our moral standards. It is easy to cheat and to deceive a global corporation because they are things; they are not human beings. But in relations to real human beings who live close to us, we find ourselves hesitating to practice deceit and dishonesty. It is more difficult to look in the face of the persons you have defrauded. Our moral obligations to our neighbors, like family members, are very powerful.
We should respond to reports of dishonesty from all quarters by redoubling our efforts to maintain human communities. For many city dwellers, their neighbors are as distant as the strangers on the bus. Go out and meet your neighbors; if there are problems you can try to tackle them together You can improve your neighborhood, get it cleaned up, make it more livable. Only a place where people know one another and work together for common goals will support a common morality.
Wednesday, December 3, 2008
Rampant Dishonesty
Labels:free market, religion, science and faith
community,
corruption
Sunday, November 2, 2008
A Real Bailout
With a great deal of fanfare and soul searching, Congress decided to spend close to a trillion dollars to bail out banks, insurance companies, hedge funds (most of us, including myself, do not even know what those hedge funds do.) They should have been hesitant because that trillion dollars is not their money. Unfortunately, it is not ours either. The government will have to borrow it. And how do you go and get a loan of a trillion dollars at a times when credit has dried up?
In the midst of all this astronomical expenditure to bail out financial institutions, who worries about the homeowners who are losing their house to foreclosure? Yes, politicians worry about that but what are they doing about it? You guessed: not a lot.
One reason is that giving billions of dollars to one American Insurance Group (AIG) is a lot less paper work than giving $ 50,000 to millions of individual homeowners. The other reason is, of course that AIG has friends in high places and the poor family on your block who have had to leave their home because they could not pay their mortgage have no friends among bankers or politicians.
It is nevertheless clear what needs to be done. The government must—they should have done that more than a year ago—declare a moratorium on foreclosures. No more foreclosures, basta.
How would it work? Every city and town might appoint a number of boards to sit down with each homeowner who is unable to pay the mortgage and the institutions that gave the mortgage and work out a deal that keeps the family in their house. If some money is needed to complete that deal what better use of the 1 trillion dollars, appropriated by Congress? Keeping the families in their house, and mortgages—properly adjusted-- in play is good for families. It is good for neighborhoods and the whole city. It is good for the banks.
There would probably be other ways of working out the administrative details. What matters is the will to help ordinary citizens to remain in their homes.
Well, you say: it would be a bureaucratic nightmare. For sure, but having millions of hard working citizens kicked out of their house is not a nightmare? What sort of nightmare would we rather have—one for bureaucrats or one for people who see their belongings piled up on the sidewalk by the Sheriff's deputies and bailiffs?
There has been a lot of talk about change in this presidential campaign. How would this be for a departure from business as usual?
In the midst of all this astronomical expenditure to bail out financial institutions, who worries about the homeowners who are losing their house to foreclosure? Yes, politicians worry about that but what are they doing about it? You guessed: not a lot.
One reason is that giving billions of dollars to one American Insurance Group (AIG) is a lot less paper work than giving $ 50,000 to millions of individual homeowners. The other reason is, of course that AIG has friends in high places and the poor family on your block who have had to leave their home because they could not pay their mortgage have no friends among bankers or politicians.
It is nevertheless clear what needs to be done. The government must—they should have done that more than a year ago—declare a moratorium on foreclosures. No more foreclosures, basta.
How would it work? Every city and town might appoint a number of boards to sit down with each homeowner who is unable to pay the mortgage and the institutions that gave the mortgage and work out a deal that keeps the family in their house. If some money is needed to complete that deal what better use of the 1 trillion dollars, appropriated by Congress? Keeping the families in their house, and mortgages—properly adjusted-- in play is good for families. It is good for neighborhoods and the whole city. It is good for the banks.
There would probably be other ways of working out the administrative details. What matters is the will to help ordinary citizens to remain in their homes.
Well, you say: it would be a bureaucratic nightmare. For sure, but having millions of hard working citizens kicked out of their house is not a nightmare? What sort of nightmare would we rather have—one for bureaucrats or one for people who see their belongings piled up on the sidewalk by the Sheriff's deputies and bailiffs?
There has been a lot of talk about change in this presidential campaign. How would this be for a departure from business as usual?
Saturday, November 1, 2008
Greed?
A while ago when it became obvious that we are in serious economic trouble, the President and other leaders said “the economy has some problems but its fundamentals are sound.” Today they tell us that we facing recession, perhaps depression. The fundamentals are no longer sound but it is all due to the greed of individuals. The system as a whole is sound. The capitalist system, the free market do not bear any blame for the present economic crisis. It is the greed of individuals.
When they said that the economy is sound-- that was propaganda. Now they tell us that the economic system is sound. There were just some bad apples that were carried away by greed. Shall we believe them this time, or is this more propaganda?
Imagine that you own a bank. That does not mean that the bank's money is yours; you only run the bank. The bank's money belongs to the depositors or to stock holders who invested their money in your bank. You have been a banker for a long time. You believe that it is your obligation to be conservative in your investment and in the loans you make because the money you handle is, after all, not yours. It has been entrusted to you.
So when you hear about other banks giving mortgages to people with a poor credit record and insufficient income to pay for them, or if other banks make serious profit investing in financial papers that you do not completely understand and you are sure that the other banks don't either, you refuse to participate. Yes, the high profits are tempting, but you are committed to being cautious.
But one day you get a phone call from a major stock holder. He wants to complain. Your local competitor—the bank across the street from you, in fact—is making a lot more money than your bank. They have discovered a goldmine; they are investing in mortgages given to people who are poor credit risks. The competing bank also invested, and reaped significant profits, from all kinds of new fangled investment instruments. You regard both of those unsafe, in the long run, and have therefore stayed away from them. Your profit rate, due to your cautious way of investing money, is significantly lower than that of most other banks around.
Your stockholder is not only complaining about the lower rate of profit and therefore the lower dividends paid to stockholders, but he wants you to change. If you refuse, he suggests, he will try to get the board of directors to fire you, in order to hire a more aggressive banker who is willing to take more risks and earn more money for the stock holders. In short your job is on the line. If you want to keep it, you need to change your ways. Caution may be all very well in the long run, but your stockholders want more money now.
What should you do? Will you give up your job or make riskier investments? If you do the latter it is not because you are greedy, but because the competition in the banking industry forces you to do what everyone else does. If you want to remain in your job, you need to meet the stockholders' demands and give up your cautious ways.
(Today when the government has bought a portion of your bank because the risky investment you made, along with all the other bankers, went bad your bank is in serious trouble. Now you can think to yourself that you were right all along, but your bank is in trouble anyway because you yielded to the pressures of the stockholders.)
Our economic system is a competitive one. Any business must follow the practices of all competitors or go bankrupt. If you competitors in a service industry pay minimum wage to their employees, you must do the same otherwise you will be unable to compete in price. If your competitors in a manufacturing industry send their manufacturing off shore, to China, where wages are a fraction of what they are here, you too must move your manufacturing to a low wage area and take the jobs from working people at home. If you run a bank you need to be as profitable as all the other ones even if that means making investments which you regard—rightly so it turns out now—too risky.
But, you say, maybe it was not the bankers, or the mortgage companies, the hedge fund managers or other large scale investors who were greedy, but the stockholders who were calling for higher profits. But is that not precisely what they are supposed to do? People like the President talk endlessly about the great system we have where individual enterprise creates a good life for everyone. But what is “individual enterprise” but another name for trying to make as much money as possible? And what's the difference between trying to make as much money as you can and greed? The greedy never has enough. The greedy always want more. So do the capitalist entrepreneurs who want to make as much money as they can.
When the pundits tell us that it is greed that has brought us this economic crisis, they want us to think that the economic system is sound, and it is just some “bad apples” who are very different from us. But anyone who runs a business in our capitalist system must try to make as much money as she or he can. It is not individuals who are poorly brought up or other wise morally defective who are greedy, it is anyone who is in the uisiness world and wants to remain in it. Greed is not a deviation; it is built into the system.
If greed is the problem, it is a systematic feature that will be with us as long as we think about business as we do today, as the way to make as much money as possible.
When they said that the economy is sound-- that was propaganda. Now they tell us that the economic system is sound. There were just some bad apples that were carried away by greed. Shall we believe them this time, or is this more propaganda?
Imagine that you own a bank. That does not mean that the bank's money is yours; you only run the bank. The bank's money belongs to the depositors or to stock holders who invested their money in your bank. You have been a banker for a long time. You believe that it is your obligation to be conservative in your investment and in the loans you make because the money you handle is, after all, not yours. It has been entrusted to you.
So when you hear about other banks giving mortgages to people with a poor credit record and insufficient income to pay for them, or if other banks make serious profit investing in financial papers that you do not completely understand and you are sure that the other banks don't either, you refuse to participate. Yes, the high profits are tempting, but you are committed to being cautious.
But one day you get a phone call from a major stock holder. He wants to complain. Your local competitor—the bank across the street from you, in fact—is making a lot more money than your bank. They have discovered a goldmine; they are investing in mortgages given to people who are poor credit risks. The competing bank also invested, and reaped significant profits, from all kinds of new fangled investment instruments. You regard both of those unsafe, in the long run, and have therefore stayed away from them. Your profit rate, due to your cautious way of investing money, is significantly lower than that of most other banks around.
Your stockholder is not only complaining about the lower rate of profit and therefore the lower dividends paid to stockholders, but he wants you to change. If you refuse, he suggests, he will try to get the board of directors to fire you, in order to hire a more aggressive banker who is willing to take more risks and earn more money for the stock holders. In short your job is on the line. If you want to keep it, you need to change your ways. Caution may be all very well in the long run, but your stockholders want more money now.
What should you do? Will you give up your job or make riskier investments? If you do the latter it is not because you are greedy, but because the competition in the banking industry forces you to do what everyone else does. If you want to remain in your job, you need to meet the stockholders' demands and give up your cautious ways.
(Today when the government has bought a portion of your bank because the risky investment you made, along with all the other bankers, went bad your bank is in serious trouble. Now you can think to yourself that you were right all along, but your bank is in trouble anyway because you yielded to the pressures of the stockholders.)
Our economic system is a competitive one. Any business must follow the practices of all competitors or go bankrupt. If you competitors in a service industry pay minimum wage to their employees, you must do the same otherwise you will be unable to compete in price. If your competitors in a manufacturing industry send their manufacturing off shore, to China, where wages are a fraction of what they are here, you too must move your manufacturing to a low wage area and take the jobs from working people at home. If you run a bank you need to be as profitable as all the other ones even if that means making investments which you regard—rightly so it turns out now—too risky.
But, you say, maybe it was not the bankers, or the mortgage companies, the hedge fund managers or other large scale investors who were greedy, but the stockholders who were calling for higher profits. But is that not precisely what they are supposed to do? People like the President talk endlessly about the great system we have where individual enterprise creates a good life for everyone. But what is “individual enterprise” but another name for trying to make as much money as possible? And what's the difference between trying to make as much money as you can and greed? The greedy never has enough. The greedy always want more. So do the capitalist entrepreneurs who want to make as much money as they can.
When the pundits tell us that it is greed that has brought us this economic crisis, they want us to think that the economic system is sound, and it is just some “bad apples” who are very different from us. But anyone who runs a business in our capitalist system must try to make as much money as she or he can. It is not individuals who are poorly brought up or other wise morally defective who are greedy, it is anyone who is in the uisiness world and wants to remain in it. Greed is not a deviation; it is built into the system.
If greed is the problem, it is a systematic feature that will be with us as long as we think about business as we do today, as the way to make as much money as possible.
Labels:free market, religion, science and faith
capitalism,
greed
Monday, October 20, 2008
Voting for Obama
Yes you should vote for Obama but you should also know what not to expect if he wins:
Obama has collected more than $600 million in campaign funds. In the last month he has collected more than ever before. As it appears that he may win the election, every one who has the resources to buy access to the highest levels of government, is putting money into the pot so that next year, or the year after, if they need something done for them, they can call the White House and say "remember me I gave a large amount of money to your campaign two years ago."
If you expect government to be cleaner than it has been, you will be disappointed. Our system still is run by money. Money talks; not citizens. Obama getting elected is not going to change that.
Obama has spoken frequently about his extended opposition to the Iraq war. But in the course of the it has become clear that he is not going to change the dominant attitude of the US government toward the rest of the world. Obama may well believe, as do most people, that the war in Iraq was and is a terrible mistake. But he does believe that it is good for the United States to act as if we were entitled to tell everyone else what to do.
Yes Obama talks more about diplomacy, about even talking to our enemies. But that is all a question of the mechanics of being the most powerful nation in the world. If you have any hope that our country will stop being the world's biggest bully, don't expect that change from Obama. There is no reason to think that he would willingly cede any US power to other allies, or to international organizations.
Some of us believe that what we need is radical change. That means for instance that we have health care for all but cut out the insurance companies which currently, according to some sources, are earning $350 billion from health insurance. We have to pay those $350 billion but do not get any health care for that money which is just there to enrich the insurance company. Radical change means a single payer health care system that cuts out the insurance companies altogether. Obama's health care plan leans heavily on the private insurance companies to pay for health care for most citizens.
Radical change in the economy would go beyond regulating financial institutions to keep them from producing periodic crises, like the current one, when the people have to make up for the losses of the so-called "financial experts." What we have at present more than one witty commentator has pointed out is “socialization of losses and privatization of gain.” Radical change in the economy would equalize incomes so that everybody has a decent life and the difference in income between the rich and the poor is lower than its current 400 to 1. Radical change would mean that everybody has health care and decent education not only the children of the rich. Radical change would take on the matter of awful jobs, of job safety, of boring jobs, of tyrannical supervisors. Radical change would mean that everybody is entitled to decent working conditions.
While Obama talks all the time about "change," he is not going to produce radical change. He will make the world safer for business as usual.
But as long as we will have business as usual, we might just as well get a good version of it. McCain is for war. The present wars have cost many lives of Americans and others and are continuing to do so. There is no sign that they are increasing security for anyone. The financial cost of these adventures is astronomical.
McCain is on the side of big business; he is for deregulation. Deregulation is what has gotten us into our present mess. Deregulation is part of a religious faith in what they choose to call "the free market." It is a religious faith because it is not supported by evidence, by science, let alone by common sense. It is a religious faith because it is unshakable in the face of contrary evidence. The present financial crisis does not shake the faith of the free marketeers in the benefits of the unregulated market because nothing will ever do that. But being so proof against contradictory evidence is the mark of a religious belief.
Like Bush, McCain does not believe in being reasonable, objective, looking the facts in the face. As his running mate he chose a woman who is, however energetic and positive, plain ignorant. McCain has no respect for intelligence, for knowing things. He goes on his hunches.
If you have a choice of doctors, one of whom tries to keep up with current medical research while the other goes on his hunches, which would you choose? The same applies to presidents. You want someone who tries to get as much relevant information on any topic as is available before making a choice. Running our government is a complicated and very difficult job. Any sensible person would try to get as much information and expert opinion as available. He would look for a running mate who knows a lot about government.
McCain did not do that.
Here are good reasons for voting for of Obama. His opponent is totally unacceptable. His opponent also is burdened by the colossal failure of eight years of Republican governance.
But Obama will not bring radical change to our economic system. He will not re-fashion our foreign policy to be less macho, less inspired by Rambo and more by ordinary standards of decent human behavior. Obama's picks for his team may not be quite as unfortunate as some of George Bush's choices. But the basic system of cronyism, of helping your friends that have helped you with campaign funds is going to remain with us. Politics will not be less corrupt.
Whoever you vote for—remember that the election may end up being fixed. It would not be the first time that we owe our president to crooked election officials.
Obama has collected more than $600 million in campaign funds. In the last month he has collected more than ever before. As it appears that he may win the election, every one who has the resources to buy access to the highest levels of government, is putting money into the pot so that next year, or the year after, if they need something done for them, they can call the White House and say "remember me I gave a large amount of money to your campaign two years ago."
If you expect government to be cleaner than it has been, you will be disappointed. Our system still is run by money. Money talks; not citizens. Obama getting elected is not going to change that.
Obama has spoken frequently about his extended opposition to the Iraq war. But in the course of the it has become clear that he is not going to change the dominant attitude of the US government toward the rest of the world. Obama may well believe, as do most people, that the war in Iraq was and is a terrible mistake. But he does believe that it is good for the United States to act as if we were entitled to tell everyone else what to do.
Yes Obama talks more about diplomacy, about even talking to our enemies. But that is all a question of the mechanics of being the most powerful nation in the world. If you have any hope that our country will stop being the world's biggest bully, don't expect that change from Obama. There is no reason to think that he would willingly cede any US power to other allies, or to international organizations.
Some of us believe that what we need is radical change. That means for instance that we have health care for all but cut out the insurance companies which currently, according to some sources, are earning $350 billion from health insurance. We have to pay those $350 billion but do not get any health care for that money which is just there to enrich the insurance company. Radical change means a single payer health care system that cuts out the insurance companies altogether. Obama's health care plan leans heavily on the private insurance companies to pay for health care for most citizens.
Radical change in the economy would go beyond regulating financial institutions to keep them from producing periodic crises, like the current one, when the people have to make up for the losses of the so-called "financial experts." What we have at present more than one witty commentator has pointed out is “socialization of losses and privatization of gain.” Radical change in the economy would equalize incomes so that everybody has a decent life and the difference in income between the rich and the poor is lower than its current 400 to 1. Radical change would mean that everybody has health care and decent education not only the children of the rich. Radical change would take on the matter of awful jobs, of job safety, of boring jobs, of tyrannical supervisors. Radical change would mean that everybody is entitled to decent working conditions.
While Obama talks all the time about "change," he is not going to produce radical change. He will make the world safer for business as usual.
But as long as we will have business as usual, we might just as well get a good version of it. McCain is for war. The present wars have cost many lives of Americans and others and are continuing to do so. There is no sign that they are increasing security for anyone. The financial cost of these adventures is astronomical.
McCain is on the side of big business; he is for deregulation. Deregulation is what has gotten us into our present mess. Deregulation is part of a religious faith in what they choose to call "the free market." It is a religious faith because it is not supported by evidence, by science, let alone by common sense. It is a religious faith because it is unshakable in the face of contrary evidence. The present financial crisis does not shake the faith of the free marketeers in the benefits of the unregulated market because nothing will ever do that. But being so proof against contradictory evidence is the mark of a religious belief.
Like Bush, McCain does not believe in being reasonable, objective, looking the facts in the face. As his running mate he chose a woman who is, however energetic and positive, plain ignorant. McCain has no respect for intelligence, for knowing things. He goes on his hunches.
If you have a choice of doctors, one of whom tries to keep up with current medical research while the other goes on his hunches, which would you choose? The same applies to presidents. You want someone who tries to get as much relevant information on any topic as is available before making a choice. Running our government is a complicated and very difficult job. Any sensible person would try to get as much information and expert opinion as available. He would look for a running mate who knows a lot about government.
McCain did not do that.
Here are good reasons for voting for of Obama. His opponent is totally unacceptable. His opponent also is burdened by the colossal failure of eight years of Republican governance.
But Obama will not bring radical change to our economic system. He will not re-fashion our foreign policy to be less macho, less inspired by Rambo and more by ordinary standards of decent human behavior. Obama's picks for his team may not be quite as unfortunate as some of George Bush's choices. But the basic system of cronyism, of helping your friends that have helped you with campaign funds is going to remain with us. Politics will not be less corrupt.
Whoever you vote for—remember that the election may end up being fixed. It would not be the first time that we owe our president to crooked election officials.
Labels:free market, religion, science and faith
elections
Saturday, October 4, 2008
The Bailout and Democracy
The current financial crisis is not only a disaster for the economy but it exposes in the starkest terms the collapse of American democracy.
A significant number of legislators in Congress, both Democrats and Republicans, refused to vote for the first version of the $700 billion bailout bill because they got a lot of heat from their constituents. Why bail out the banks and not help the people who are losing or have lost their homes because someone tricked them into buying a balloon mortgage? Why bailout the big banks and investment firms without penalizing them for their terribly bad judgment? We are being told over and over again that many of the bankers and investors who lost billions of dollars bought securities which they did not completely understand. It is quite clear that a large part of responsibility for the current economic situation rests with large banks and their leadership. But Congress is being asked to spend an unbelievably large sum of public money to rescue them without holding them responsible.
The bailout pointedly ignores ordinary citizens. Ordinary citizens are held responsible for their lack of judgment or care in buying their homes. A while ago when the suggestion was made to help homeowners who lost their homes, the President refused to take the suggestion on the grounds that we do not want to encourage people to be irresponsible. The lesson is clear: if you are irresponsible in a small way, stand in the corner and be ashamed of yourself and then go live in your car. But if you are irresponsible to the tune of many many billions of dollars, the government will help you out.
Congress is about to pass a bailout bill. It does not contain significant help for homeowners. It does not contain serious punishment for irresponsible investors.
Add to all of this the fact that those $700 billion come out of taxpayer's pocket because that's the only place government gets money. Since the government already is in debt over its ears, it will simply have to borrow more money and our children and grandchildren will have to pay back, to make up for the bad judgments and irresponsibility of the likes of Merrill Lynch and Lehman Brothers.
But then you say: wait a minute. Is this not supposed to be government of the people, for the people, and by the people? Is that not what they taught us in school? Did they not tell us that we control the government through the mechanism of electing representatives who either fulfill our wishes or will be punished by not being reelected?
But if these representatives represent us, the people, how can they take our money and give it to the people who already have more than they possibly need over many lifetimes?
In this way this financial crisis is also a deep crisis for democracy because it shows that ours is not a people's government.
On Wednesday, October 1, 2008 the Boston Globe ran this paragraph:
"A nonpartisan watchdog group calculated that U.S. Congress members who voted yes [to the proposed bailout plan] received 51% more in campaign contributions from the finance, insurance, and real estate sector in their congressional careers than those who opposed the emergency legislation."
The big banks insurance companies and real estate interests have bought a lot of representatives. Their money counts for whole lot more with these representatives than the votes from their electorate. These Representatives voted to bailout their benefactors. Congressional representatives less generously gifted by a banking and insurance and real estate listened to their voters more closely and voted against the bill.
Obviuously, this is a grand generalization. Not every Representative who voted to support the bailout is bought off by large financial institutions. Not every Representative who opposed the bailout did so from regard of ordinary ctizens. But the numbers cited convey a grim message: taking Congress as a whole, the votes go where the money comes from. Orinary citizens count for very little.
This crisis not only shows how fragile our economy is. It also shows that our democracy is in terrible trouble.
Can we still bail it out?
A significant number of legislators in Congress, both Democrats and Republicans, refused to vote for the first version of the $700 billion bailout bill because they got a lot of heat from their constituents. Why bail out the banks and not help the people who are losing or have lost their homes because someone tricked them into buying a balloon mortgage? Why bailout the big banks and investment firms without penalizing them for their terribly bad judgment? We are being told over and over again that many of the bankers and investors who lost billions of dollars bought securities which they did not completely understand. It is quite clear that a large part of responsibility for the current economic situation rests with large banks and their leadership. But Congress is being asked to spend an unbelievably large sum of public money to rescue them without holding them responsible.
The bailout pointedly ignores ordinary citizens. Ordinary citizens are held responsible for their lack of judgment or care in buying their homes. A while ago when the suggestion was made to help homeowners who lost their homes, the President refused to take the suggestion on the grounds that we do not want to encourage people to be irresponsible. The lesson is clear: if you are irresponsible in a small way, stand in the corner and be ashamed of yourself and then go live in your car. But if you are irresponsible to the tune of many many billions of dollars, the government will help you out.
Congress is about to pass a bailout bill. It does not contain significant help for homeowners. It does not contain serious punishment for irresponsible investors.
Add to all of this the fact that those $700 billion come out of taxpayer's pocket because that's the only place government gets money. Since the government already is in debt over its ears, it will simply have to borrow more money and our children and grandchildren will have to pay back, to make up for the bad judgments and irresponsibility of the likes of Merrill Lynch and Lehman Brothers.
But then you say: wait a minute. Is this not supposed to be government of the people, for the people, and by the people? Is that not what they taught us in school? Did they not tell us that we control the government through the mechanism of electing representatives who either fulfill our wishes or will be punished by not being reelected?
But if these representatives represent us, the people, how can they take our money and give it to the people who already have more than they possibly need over many lifetimes?
In this way this financial crisis is also a deep crisis for democracy because it shows that ours is not a people's government.
On Wednesday, October 1, 2008 the Boston Globe ran this paragraph:
"A nonpartisan watchdog group calculated that U.S. Congress members who voted yes [to the proposed bailout plan] received 51% more in campaign contributions from the finance, insurance, and real estate sector in their congressional careers than those who opposed the emergency legislation."
The big banks insurance companies and real estate interests have bought a lot of representatives. Their money counts for whole lot more with these representatives than the votes from their electorate. These Representatives voted to bailout their benefactors. Congressional representatives less generously gifted by a banking and insurance and real estate listened to their voters more closely and voted against the bill.
Obviuously, this is a grand generalization. Not every Representative who voted to support the bailout is bought off by large financial institutions. Not every Representative who opposed the bailout did so from regard of ordinary ctizens. But the numbers cited convey a grim message: taking Congress as a whole, the votes go where the money comes from. Orinary citizens count for very little.
This crisis not only shows how fragile our economy is. It also shows that our democracy is in terrible trouble.
Can we still bail it out?
Labels:free market, religion, science and faith
democracy
Sunday, September 21, 2008
Regulating the Markets
Last week, Sen. McCain came out in favor of regulating financial markets. That is a departure from traditional Republican orthodoxy that is truly astonishing. For 100 years or more, Republicans and many Democrats have told us that markets are "self-regulating." It does not matter what market you are talking about -- market for consumer goods, for machinery, for finance capital such as bank loans or mortgages -- sooner or later supply will meet demand and prices will reach a reasonable level. Markets do not need government regulation; on the contrary economic problems are caused by government regulation.
But now this orthodoxy has been given up by almost everyone who has trumpeted it for many years including the White House and Republican stalwarts like Sen. McCain. The new orthodoxy is that we must return to a law (adopted during the Great Depression after 1929 and abolished under Pres. Clinton) that separated ordinary banks from investment banks. Ordinary banks are where you deposit your paycheck, maybe open a savings account, and borrow money to buy a house or a car. Investment banks do not do any of that; they operate with large sums of investment funds and, frankly, gamble with those funds trying to make money. For a while everybody wins and then, as is happening currently, the bottom drops out and many people lose. (The CEO’s of bankrupt investment houses walk off with $200 million for their old age.) But we are now being told that all of this could be avoided if only we do not allow ordinary banks to gamble in the way of investment and if, secondly, we kept a closer eye on the investment banks’ gambling.
Not surprisingly, that oversimplifies our problem. In the last 40 years there have been regular government bailouts of private businesses -- the Pennsylvania Railroad in 1970, the Franklin National Bank and New York City in 1975, Chrysler in 1980, the Savings and Loan Banks in 1990, the airline industry in 2002, and now one investment bank after another to the tune of close to $1 trillion.
It is clearly not true that in all these different cases the problem was a confusion of ordinary and investment banking. Many of the bailouts occurred when ordinary and investment banks were still distinct. Our economic system has pervasive problems which our experts and legislators still do not want to recognize.
Here is just one of them. In a capitalist system everyone pursues his or her private interest and the "unseen hand" of the market is supposed to assure us that the outcome will be the best for all of us. You look after what's good for you; I look after myself and you and I and everyone else will be better off. Let's look at that.
Suppose you have a small business. You manufacture specialty paints. Your business does okay but your profit margin is small. Then, one day, you have an inspiration. You see that the cost of disposing of your waste, much of it hazardous, is significant. So you begin dumping your waste in the woods, save the money of proper disposal and increase your profit. That is clearly a good strategy for you but if everybody did this, the Earth would soon become unlivable from all the pollution. The market is not going to make that problem go away. What is good for the individual often is bad if practiced by everyone.
One more example: another way of raising your profit margin is to lower wages. Since your business is small you may even take on a few illegal immigrants and pay them less than minimum wage. The government is never going to check a small business like yours..
This strategy too will increase your profits and be good for you. If all enterprises follow the same policy the large majority of the population would have a lot less money at their disposal. Demand for ordinary consumption goods would fall and some businesses would go broke and the economy would go into a recession, if not worse. Policies that significantly decrease consumer demand are not good for the economy even though they may be very good for individual enterprises.
There is no reason to think that capitalist markets regulate themselves. Capitalist enterprises must be carefully supervised so that they do not adopt policies that are harmful to the economy as a whole.
The current crisis is the result of the religious faith in the self-regulating market -- a faith that has no support in actual fact. It is supported only by the self interest of capitalist enterprisers who do not want to be limited in the ways they make money, even if their methods are in the short or in the long run bad for consumers or the country as a whole.
This blatant self-interest of the pundits associated with business is still at work when they try to tell us that we just need to restore a one law that separates ordinary from investment banks and then everything will be fine. Unless the government takes a firm hand to protect us against capitalists, we will never be fine.
But since the capitalists own the government, for instance because they pay for the presidential of campaigns of Obama and McCain, we are bound to hear misleading diagnoses of our present problems. Ordinary citizens and voters should not believe everything they're told.
But now this orthodoxy has been given up by almost everyone who has trumpeted it for many years including the White House and Republican stalwarts like Sen. McCain. The new orthodoxy is that we must return to a law (adopted during the Great Depression after 1929 and abolished under Pres. Clinton) that separated ordinary banks from investment banks. Ordinary banks are where you deposit your paycheck, maybe open a savings account, and borrow money to buy a house or a car. Investment banks do not do any of that; they operate with large sums of investment funds and, frankly, gamble with those funds trying to make money. For a while everybody wins and then, as is happening currently, the bottom drops out and many people lose. (The CEO’s of bankrupt investment houses walk off with $200 million for their old age.) But we are now being told that all of this could be avoided if only we do not allow ordinary banks to gamble in the way of investment and if, secondly, we kept a closer eye on the investment banks’ gambling.
Not surprisingly, that oversimplifies our problem. In the last 40 years there have been regular government bailouts of private businesses -- the Pennsylvania Railroad in 1970, the Franklin National Bank and New York City in 1975, Chrysler in 1980, the Savings and Loan Banks in 1990, the airline industry in 2002, and now one investment bank after another to the tune of close to $1 trillion.
It is clearly not true that in all these different cases the problem was a confusion of ordinary and investment banking. Many of the bailouts occurred when ordinary and investment banks were still distinct. Our economic system has pervasive problems which our experts and legislators still do not want to recognize.
Here is just one of them. In a capitalist system everyone pursues his or her private interest and the "unseen hand" of the market is supposed to assure us that the outcome will be the best for all of us. You look after what's good for you; I look after myself and you and I and everyone else will be better off. Let's look at that.
Suppose you have a small business. You manufacture specialty paints. Your business does okay but your profit margin is small. Then, one day, you have an inspiration. You see that the cost of disposing of your waste, much of it hazardous, is significant. So you begin dumping your waste in the woods, save the money of proper disposal and increase your profit. That is clearly a good strategy for you but if everybody did this, the Earth would soon become unlivable from all the pollution. The market is not going to make that problem go away. What is good for the individual often is bad if practiced by everyone.
One more example: another way of raising your profit margin is to lower wages. Since your business is small you may even take on a few illegal immigrants and pay them less than minimum wage. The government is never going to check a small business like yours..
This strategy too will increase your profits and be good for you. If all enterprises follow the same policy the large majority of the population would have a lot less money at their disposal. Demand for ordinary consumption goods would fall and some businesses would go broke and the economy would go into a recession, if not worse. Policies that significantly decrease consumer demand are not good for the economy even though they may be very good for individual enterprises.
There is no reason to think that capitalist markets regulate themselves. Capitalist enterprises must be carefully supervised so that they do not adopt policies that are harmful to the economy as a whole.
The current crisis is the result of the religious faith in the self-regulating market -- a faith that has no support in actual fact. It is supported only by the self interest of capitalist enterprisers who do not want to be limited in the ways they make money, even if their methods are in the short or in the long run bad for consumers or the country as a whole.
This blatant self-interest of the pundits associated with business is still at work when they try to tell us that we just need to restore a one law that separates ordinary from investment banks and then everything will be fine. Unless the government takes a firm hand to protect us against capitalists, we will never be fine.
But since the capitalists own the government, for instance because they pay for the presidential of campaigns of Obama and McCain, we are bound to hear misleading diagnoses of our present problems. Ordinary citizens and voters should not believe everything they're told.
Labels:free market, religion, science and faith
blind faith,
capitalism,
free markets,
regulation
Sunday, September 14, 2008
Our Power
Americans have long felt aggrieved by the 9/11. Here we are the most powerful nation of the world, completely innocent, sneakily attacked by a bunch of terrorists, mostly from Saudi Arabia, a firm ally of ours in the Mideast. We found ourselves in a "war on terrorism."
Seven years later, it is time to think again about what happened there. Is it really true that we are "the most powerful nation on earth"?
Many people think that our power rests on two pillars: our military and our economy. Our military consumes more than half of the annual expenditures of the US government. That enormous sum pays for the costs of past wars and the maintenance of the current military establishment, including the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan. We have been fighting those two wars for more than five years -- longer than either World War I or World War II. So far it is not clear that we have won. Our military has been victorious only in attacks on tiny, tiny countries when Pres. Reagan attacked the Caribbean island nation of Grenada, and the elder Bush attacked the small nation of Panama. We have lost most serious wars since the middle of the last century. We lost to the North Vietnamese during the war in Vietnam and were fought to a draw by the Chinese during the war in Korea. Yes, it is true that we have enough nuclear weapons to annihilate all human life on earth. Yes it is also true that our military is more high tech than anyone else's but once again we seem to be unable to win out over the homemade explosives of shadowy opponents in Iraq or the Taliban of Afghanistan -- neither of them as well equipped as we are.
9/11 is just one more example of that. When the planes left Logan Airport and disappeared from the radar we could not even get our fighter planes up in the air. We were defenseless in spite of all the incredible expenditure for the military.
As to our economic power, the United States owes the $31,000 for every man, woman and child living in our country. We are heavily indebted; our debt is growing with every year at the same time as we have no money to keep up our roads and bridges, to give a decent education to all children, or to provide a minimally acceptable life for everyone. At the moment we can't even provide jobs for everyone or guarantee a roof over their head.
So much for two pillars of our power: our military is not equipped to fight our actual enemies. Our economy is in shambles. But there is a whole other aspect of national power which we have not even mentioned yet.
During the Vietnam war, the North Vietnamese moved troops and weapons and supplies through the jungles on bicycles. Due to a massive national effort they managed to defeat a richer and much better equipped, a "more powerful" enemy. The power of the nation does not only depend on its money and its weapons. The power of a nation, in the end, depends on the dedication of its citizens to national goals and to maintaining national institutions.
During World War II, the whole nation pitched in. "There was a war on" and everything was different; many people gladly made great sacrifices. But lately we have been unable to mobilize our national energies. After 9/11, President Bush did not call for a national mobilization. He told people to go shopping. No national coming together was called for or ever thought about. Bumper stickers saying "United we stand" was all we could do as a response to the attack on the World Trade Center and the Pentagon.
Only half of all Americans vote in presidential elections. 9/11 and the wars we are fighting abroad have not changed that. The military can barely fill its ranks and its recruits are overwhelmingly drawn from the poor for whom we do not manage to provide the prospects of decent work for decent pay. Ours is not an army of the people; it is an army of those who have few other alternatives or, more and more, an army of foreigners who join in order to get a green card or citizenship.
In the last 50 years, American political life has undergone profound changes. Our political parties used to be large organizations closely connected to ordinary voters. Every precinct and ward had their party organizations, further subdivided into individual block committees. The parties employed a large network of volunteers whose job it was to know the people on their block, to listen to their grievances and to get them to vote for their candidate at election time.
The same was true of other organizations that had political agendas -- ethnic organizations, opponents of alcohol, PTA's and such. American democracy involved a significant number of citizens. Today the only role for citizens in politics is to send money. They neither work in the organization nor have any say when it comes to making policy.
Politics has become thoroughly professionalized. It is the business of full-time, paid operatives; citizens do not participate. If they do, if they take a grievances to a city counselor or to City Hall, they may get a hearing -- if they're lucky -- but the odds are that no one will take their recommendations seriously. They may be listened to but will not be heard. Professional politicians and bureaucrats are in charge -- citizens no longer have any power. They vote and after that they are supposed to disappear quietly.
As a result citizens have become passive. They do not trust the government to pay attention to them. Even if they face serious problems, they complain to their friends but not to the government, for what's the use?
One example of that: as the new school year begins, many school districts are unable to provide the most basic supplies such as pencils or toilet paper. The schools must appeal to parents to provide these essential items. But we hear no loud complaints about that.
Another example: more than two thirds of the electorate want the war in Iraq to end. There is no sign that anyone in the government is paying serious attention to that.
We have become weak in spite of our arsenal of atomic bombs because we lack unity as a nation. We have fragmented into different groups. There is the government and its bureaucrats. They say they represent us, but do not really. Instead they do as they please. Then there are the working Americans who barely get by these days. The government is willing to save the banks but not the houses or jobs of ordinary Americans. They work but the government looks away from them. Then there are other Americans who do not manage to get by even though many of them work more than one job. Others again will take any job if only they could get one. Their best chance is to fight America's wars.
9/11 was not an attack on us although ordinary citizens lost their lives. The airplanes attacked the US government which was even then hatching plans for Mideast wars. They had been thinking about that for years but had not talked about them. Our government does not tell us Americans what it is planning; once it has decided to go to war it tries to sell that project to us by telling lies. It stages elaborate electoral campaigns to make us think that it represents us.
9/11 and its aftermath exposes the weakness of America: all our smart bombs are no remedy for the weakness of the nation whose government has separated itself from the people.
Seven years later, it is time to think again about what happened there. Is it really true that we are "the most powerful nation on earth"?
Many people think that our power rests on two pillars: our military and our economy. Our military consumes more than half of the annual expenditures of the US government. That enormous sum pays for the costs of past wars and the maintenance of the current military establishment, including the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan. We have been fighting those two wars for more than five years -- longer than either World War I or World War II. So far it is not clear that we have won. Our military has been victorious only in attacks on tiny, tiny countries when Pres. Reagan attacked the Caribbean island nation of Grenada, and the elder Bush attacked the small nation of Panama. We have lost most serious wars since the middle of the last century. We lost to the North Vietnamese during the war in Vietnam and were fought to a draw by the Chinese during the war in Korea. Yes, it is true that we have enough nuclear weapons to annihilate all human life on earth. Yes it is also true that our military is more high tech than anyone else's but once again we seem to be unable to win out over the homemade explosives of shadowy opponents in Iraq or the Taliban of Afghanistan -- neither of them as well equipped as we are.
9/11 is just one more example of that. When the planes left Logan Airport and disappeared from the radar we could not even get our fighter planes up in the air. We were defenseless in spite of all the incredible expenditure for the military.
As to our economic power, the United States owes the $31,000 for every man, woman and child living in our country. We are heavily indebted; our debt is growing with every year at the same time as we have no money to keep up our roads and bridges, to give a decent education to all children, or to provide a minimally acceptable life for everyone. At the moment we can't even provide jobs for everyone or guarantee a roof over their head.
So much for two pillars of our power: our military is not equipped to fight our actual enemies. Our economy is in shambles. But there is a whole other aspect of national power which we have not even mentioned yet.
During the Vietnam war, the North Vietnamese moved troops and weapons and supplies through the jungles on bicycles. Due to a massive national effort they managed to defeat a richer and much better equipped, a "more powerful" enemy. The power of the nation does not only depend on its money and its weapons. The power of a nation, in the end, depends on the dedication of its citizens to national goals and to maintaining national institutions.
During World War II, the whole nation pitched in. "There was a war on" and everything was different; many people gladly made great sacrifices. But lately we have been unable to mobilize our national energies. After 9/11, President Bush did not call for a national mobilization. He told people to go shopping. No national coming together was called for or ever thought about. Bumper stickers saying "United we stand" was all we could do as a response to the attack on the World Trade Center and the Pentagon.
Only half of all Americans vote in presidential elections. 9/11 and the wars we are fighting abroad have not changed that. The military can barely fill its ranks and its recruits are overwhelmingly drawn from the poor for whom we do not manage to provide the prospects of decent work for decent pay. Ours is not an army of the people; it is an army of those who have few other alternatives or, more and more, an army of foreigners who join in order to get a green card or citizenship.
In the last 50 years, American political life has undergone profound changes. Our political parties used to be large organizations closely connected to ordinary voters. Every precinct and ward had their party organizations, further subdivided into individual block committees. The parties employed a large network of volunteers whose job it was to know the people on their block, to listen to their grievances and to get them to vote for their candidate at election time.
The same was true of other organizations that had political agendas -- ethnic organizations, opponents of alcohol, PTA's and such. American democracy involved a significant number of citizens. Today the only role for citizens in politics is to send money. They neither work in the organization nor have any say when it comes to making policy.
Politics has become thoroughly professionalized. It is the business of full-time, paid operatives; citizens do not participate. If they do, if they take a grievances to a city counselor or to City Hall, they may get a hearing -- if they're lucky -- but the odds are that no one will take their recommendations seriously. They may be listened to but will not be heard. Professional politicians and bureaucrats are in charge -- citizens no longer have any power. They vote and after that they are supposed to disappear quietly.
As a result citizens have become passive. They do not trust the government to pay attention to them. Even if they face serious problems, they complain to their friends but not to the government, for what's the use?
One example of that: as the new school year begins, many school districts are unable to provide the most basic supplies such as pencils or toilet paper. The schools must appeal to parents to provide these essential items. But we hear no loud complaints about that.
Another example: more than two thirds of the electorate want the war in Iraq to end. There is no sign that anyone in the government is paying serious attention to that.
We have become weak in spite of our arsenal of atomic bombs because we lack unity as a nation. We have fragmented into different groups. There is the government and its bureaucrats. They say they represent us, but do not really. Instead they do as they please. Then there are the working Americans who barely get by these days. The government is willing to save the banks but not the houses or jobs of ordinary Americans. They work but the government looks away from them. Then there are other Americans who do not manage to get by even though many of them work more than one job. Others again will take any job if only they could get one. Their best chance is to fight America's wars.
9/11 was not an attack on us although ordinary citizens lost their lives. The airplanes attacked the US government which was even then hatching plans for Mideast wars. They had been thinking about that for years but had not talked about them. Our government does not tell us Americans what it is planning; once it has decided to go to war it tries to sell that project to us by telling lies. It stages elaborate electoral campaigns to make us think that it represents us.
9/11 and its aftermath exposes the weakness of America: all our smart bombs are no remedy for the weakness of the nation whose government has separated itself from the people.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)