Showing posts with label inequality. Show all posts
Showing posts with label inequality. Show all posts

Tuesday, October 11, 2016

Inequality



Anyone but the most fanatical conservative acknowledges that economic inequality is growing, not only in the United States. They are also willing to admit that growing inequality is undesirable.

One may admit that inequality is real without fully understanding what it means for its victims.


A friend, who does some sort of social work, told me this story as an illustration of what inequality means for people at the bottom of the scale.


This story is about a mother and her son. The mother is 92. She looks her age but she still hears and sees perfectly well and her mind is in excellent shape. She does not miss much. She had three children. One daughter died of cancer at age 50 a number of years ago. One wonders about the medical care she received. There are two sons. The one I know, said my friend, is in his 50s. He earns about $440 a week.


A while ago the mother had a bad fall. She injured her pelvis and needed skilled nursing care for several weeks. Medicare paid for a large portion of the nursing home cost. But the mother had to pay a $16 co-payment for each day she spent in the nursing home. That bill mounted up to more than $2000.


When the mother entered the nursing home, her son, concerned about the co-payment, talked to the nursing home management. They assured him that some way would be found to pay that $2000 bill. He was told not to worry.
The plan had been to get Medicaid to pay the co-payments. But when the bill was submitted to Medicaid, the nursing home was told that the mother had some "assets" and Medicaid could not cover the co-payments.


What were those "assets"? For the last 50 years the mother had owned a life insurance policy worth $3000. She also had a joint bank account with her daughter where her daughter kept her life’s savings – $1500. Medicaid mistakenly assumed that those $1500 belonged to the mother.


It turned out that Medicaid refused to pay the co-payment at the nursing home because the mother had a $3000 life insurance policy. After living for 92 years, most of them years of hard work, her $3000 policy disqualified her for having her nursing home costs paid for. She lived on Social Security and barely got by on that. Her son, who earned barely more than $20,000 a year, was barely in a position to contribute even marginally to her income.


As a consequence the nursing home took the mother to court to collect the $2000 owed. The mother readily admitted that she owed this sum but pointed out that she was in no position to pay.


The son said he was willing to pay $10 a month. At that rate, it would have taken more than 10 years to pay off the nursing home debt.


Had they cashed in the life insurance policy, there would have been no money to bury the mother once her day had come. She faced the choice of a pauper's grave or not paying her bills as she had done all my life.


The folks at the nursing home, who seemed to be well-meaning enough – but were not willing to leave a $2000 debt uncollected – had no suggestions. Neither did my friend who was familiar with problems of this sort. Mother and son, both  hard-working and responsible, were caught in a hopeless dilemma from which there is no escape.They cannot pay their bills and act as responsible and trustworthy citizens. In old age, the mother suffered a serious injury to her self-esteem.


Victims of inequality over and over again are faced with situations in which they have no way out. Their fellow citizens are not willing to make sure that at age 92 their financial needs are met, that they will receive the health care they require and will have a roof over their head, enough food, and money for transportation.


In our very unequal society it is not enough to be hard-working and responsible. You may nevertheless end up unable to pay your bills. However much you deserve to do so, it is difficult to hold your head up high if you cannot pay your bills or have no money for a decent funeral. 


We need to do more than deplore inequality. We need to put an end to it.

Monday, October 27, 2014


Inequality


In a recent blog I told the story of Janet Yellen, chair of the Federal Reserve Bank, who spoke about economic inequality without mentioning any of the problems in our economic system that produce and reinforce that inequality. There is a good deal of discussion of inequality these days but not many people are willing to look at the real causes of it.
A while ago, The Nation magazine reported some terribly distressing facts about one other source of economic inequality, the role that racism plays in the lives of children of color in this country.
The nation's report rested on government figures published by the US Department of Education's Office for Civil Rights. Here are some highlights from that report:
"Black students accounted for 18% of the country's pre-K enrollment, but made up 48% of preschoolers with multiple out-of-school suspensions.
Black students were expelled at three times the rate of white students.
Black girls were suspended at higher rates than all other girls and most boys.
A quarter of the schools with the highest percentage of black and Latino students did not offer Algebra II.
A third of these schools did not offer chemistry.
Less than half of American Indian and native Alaskans high school students had access to the full range of math and science courses.
Black, Latino and Native American students attended schools with higher concentrations of first-year teachers.
Black students were more than three times as likely to attend schools where fewer than 60% of teachers meet all state certifications and licensure requirements."
These stark facts help us understand the history of many young black men. In a recent book, On the Run, Alice Goffman reports that many of the young black men who are in serious difficulties with the law first ran afoul of the government when they were 10 or 11 or 12 years old. The fact that black children in preschool are already singled out for punishment and expulsion explains their early conflict with the police.
They clearly never had a chance.

Sunday, October 19, 2014


Don't believe everything they tell you.


The Federal Reserve Bank held a conference recently in Boston on economic opportunity and inequality. Janet Yellen, Chair of the Federal Reserve Rank, addressed the meeting.
She frankly admitted that inequality has been increasing rapidly in recent years. Between 1989 and 2013 the income of the top 5% of households increased 38%. The incomes of the remaining 95% of households increased by 10% or less.
What to do? Yellen had all sorts of ideas to even out the increasing inequalities in our nation. Specifically she had three suggestions: "early childhood education, affordable higher education, and increased business ownership."
Most of these are all sensible suggestions. There exists a good deal of evidence that children's school trajectories are affected by their learning in the very first few years of life. More Head Start programs might produce a better educated workforce.
College education has become terribly expensive and is prohibitive for some people. Many other students need to work, some of them full-time, in order to afford college. If students have a full-time job and go to school full-time, the odds are that they are not going to learn a lot. There is not time or energy enough to assimilate what they read or hear in class.
I am less certain about the third suggestion that more people should go into business for themselves. That takes some money doesn't it?
But I was really struck by what chairman Yellen did not talk about. Her suggestions seem peripheral. She did not address the economic problems responsible for the growing inequality.
There is still a good deal of unemployment; many people are working part-time who would prefer to work full time.
Significant numbers of people work minimum wage jobs that do not bring in enough for people to live comfortably, let alone send their kids to college.
Since the early 1970s, working-class wages have been pretty stagnant. Employers have outsourced jobs to very low wage countries, thus setting up competition between American workers and those in different Asian countries with a much lower standard of living than ours. More and more people are not regarded as employees of the firms where they work; instead, they are 'independent contractors' or they work for subcontractors. Their employment is uncertain and intermittent. Their wages are held down by competition between subcontractors.
Continuing unemployment gives employers the upper hand when it comes to negotiating wages.
All of these assaults on working-class incomes were made possible by the concerted effort of business during the Reagan administration and thereafter to destroy the powers of labor unions. Fewer and fewer workers are represented by unions. Partly as a consequence of the unions' very precarious position, they can only offer limited protection to their members.
If we look at the society as it is, it is clear that there are some more central remedies for inequality than expanded Head Start programs: raise the minimum wage, abolish Right-to- work laws (anti-– union laws), encourage unionization, and put limits on temporary employment, subcontracting and other ways of increasing business profit and impoverishing working people.
All of this is well known. Janet Yellen, of course, knows all this a lot better than I do. Why did she not say so?
There are a number of possible reasons. If she were taking the side of the workers in the struggle between workers and employers, she would be in deep trouble with the people who have most of the power. People on the right of the political spectrum, rich corporate types, would make sure that she would soon be out of a job.
On the other hand, she does not want to agree with people on the left that so many working people are suffering because the economic system is skewed against them. As the head of an important federal agency, part of her job is to tell citizens that things are really alright and that the problems you have are open to easy fixes: combat inequality by expanding Head Start.
That is of course also what people on the right want her to do: tell everyone that it is not the fault of employers if workers's wages and incomes deteriorate every year. Our actually very serious economic problems are made to look benign if they can be fixed by expanding Head Start programs.
Here then is today's lesson: don't believe what high level bureaucrats tell you about the state of the economy and of our world. They are not to be trusted.
Don't let your employers exploit you and then tell you that it is all a problem of early childhood education.

Sunday, November 20, 2011


The 1% are trying very hard 
to change the topic

For a few weeks after the Occupy Wall Street Movement first began, the media ignored it completely. 'Wall Street enriches itself at the expense of the rest of us' That's obviously silly. 'The government is in the pockets of the global corporations' What could be more idiotic!
But then 700 people were arrested crossing over to Brooklyn and the media sat up. Since then the movement has spread all around the globe. There have been protests in Egypt, South Africa, and Tunisia. Close to twenty Canadian cities have Occupy protest groups. Protests and occupations in Argentina and Brazil and thirteen other South American countries, as well as in 33 countries in Europe. And on and on. The world is erupting in protests against global capitalism, against the corrupting of democracy, against the overweening power of global corporations and their international organizations such as the International Monetary Fund and the World Bank.
Mayor Bloomberg in New York, a card carrying member of the 1%, of course, does not want to talk about the issues, about unemployment and poverty, about injustice and the suffering of many of the 99%. He does not want to talk about how the median income of working people in the US is about $26,000.00 a year, $4,000.00 above the poverty line.
Mayor Bloomberg wants to talk about keeping Zucotti Square CLEAN, he wants to talk about garbage, about security because he is so concerned about the safety of the protesters. That's why he sends in his cops in riot gear to smash their tents. That does a perfect job of muddying up the conversation. The police actions make the news. It fills the papers but the media still ignore what is really happening here.
Had he lived then, Mayor Bloomberg would certainly have had his police arrest Paul Revere for disturbing the peace. You can't have people clattering over the cobble stones in the middle of the night yelling :”The British are coming!” For heavens sake, people are trying to sleep.
Other mayors have followed that example. The Occupy movements are getting involved in legalistic discussions about where it is permitted to pitch tents. The city fathers and mothers insist that they must enforce the law about loitering, camping on the city green and other such weighty measures.
But all the while the issues raised by the protesters are ignored. They, however, patiently keep reminding us of the Preamble of the US Constitution: “We the People of the United States, in Order to form a more perfect Union, establish Justice, . . .” They want to talk about JUSTICE in America, while Mayor Bloomberg and his many colleagues around the world talk about garbage.
Its a clever attempt to avoid the issues. But it only fools the few who do not want to listen.

Wednesday, December 22, 2010



Bah, humbug!

It is Christmas. Once again we celebrate the birth of Jesus who, born into utter poverty, spent his life exhorting us to take care of the poor, to love our neighbor as much as ourselves, and to treat them as we would like to be treated.

Care of the unfortunate is part of our Christmas ritual. The Marines are collecting toys for children; newspapers carry daily photographs from different churches collecting food for the poor.

We should not allow this annual burst of benevolence to deceive us as to the reality of our practices during the remainder of the year. Pres. Obama signed the recent tax cut law with great fanfare because it is said to restore benefits for many. But this extension of benefits leaves out hundreds of thousands of Americans, unfortunate enough to have had no work for more than two years. They will not be helped by this bill. No one can get more than two years' worth of unemployment insurance even in a depression where almost 10% of workers cannot find a job. No one will help after two years. Instead the long term unemployed hear, once again the story trotted out regularly by conservatives, that we should not help the unemployed because it would make them dependent on government services. Unable to find a job, they are also getting blamed for their misfortune. (No one refused to bail out Goldman Sachs, the Bank of America or General Motors for fear that they would become dependent on public money.)

That’s hardly an example of loving your neighbor like yourself. 
 
The head of Goldman, Sachs will receive a $9 million Christmas bonus. At the same time, one in five American children lives in poverty. There have been no reports that the people at Goldman Sachs, who will receive many millions of dollars as a Christmas present, will donate their earnings to alleviate the suffering of American children. They do not love their neighbor likes themselves.

This gross inequality and complete contempt for the suffering of the poor is, of course, our fault. We adore money and bow down before its owners. Bill Gates, perhaps the richest man in the world, has recently discovered his expertise in matters of education. He has been going around blaming the teachers. And we respond by saying “Yes Mr. Gates, no Mr. Gates, Sir.” We don’t point out to Bill Gates that he knows nothing about education. He does not know, for instance, that poor children are most likely to be poor learners. We don’t tell Bill Gates to stay out of education, which he knows nothing about, and to use some of his money to alleviate child poverty. We respect money too much to do that.

Last year Exxon Mobil earned $19 billion. It paid no taxes on those $19 billion. Instead it received a tax refund from the IRS for $156 millions. Where are the congressmen and senators who called for an investigation of this complete outrage? Pres. Obama talks about reforming the tax code, but he did not call for immediate repeal of all the tax loopholes that allow Exxon Mobil to get a refund on taxes they never paid.

The unemployment rate for veterans of Iraq and Afghanistan wars reached 14.7 percent in March. There are 107,000 homeless veterans on the streets of America on any given night and over twice that many experience homelessness over the course of a year. The suicide rate of veterans is more than twice that of non-vets. 
 
Many vets suffer brain damages from explosions. But the government insurance scheme for health care for veterans refuses to pay for rehabilitative therapy which has proven effective in a significant number of cases. It's too expensive!

Congress can't find the money to create jobs for veterans or for efforts to prevent their suicides. It cannot pay for rehabilitation and therapy for gravely injured soldiers. But legislators had no trouble last week seriously cutting the taxes of people making more than $ 250,000. a year. That will cost us $ 690 billion for the next ten years. Whom does Congress and the Administration love better, the vets suffering from their service experiences or the super rich?

We Americans don’t love our poor neighbors the way we love ourselves or the super rich. Instead we blame them for their poverty and bow down respectfully to the likes of Bill Gates. We are good capitalists. We respect of the people most who make more money than anyone else.

We overlook the fact that being good capitalists makes us really bad Christians (or, equally, bad Jews or Muslims.)

Saturday, February 27, 2010

Inequality and Poverty: Haiti and the US.

Inequality and Poverty: Haiti and US.

As Haiti approaches the rainy season with its daily downpours, concern grows because the makeshift shelters in which many people are living today, will not withstand the rain. The government is planning to erect more solid tent cities but lacks sufficient open land on which to build them. Most of the real estate in the capital, Port-au-Prince, is owned by a small number of very rich people in Haiti. They are resisting having their property used to shelter the poor and the government is unlikely to prevail against them. Their wealth makes them politically very powerful; they can topple the government if they so choose. The government cannot force them to do anything, let alone to allow their land to be used for shelters for the poor.

It is a commonplace that poverty in Haiti, and elsewhere, is connected to inequality. In Haiti, there exists a very small group—perhaps 1% of the population—that is immensely rich. Everyone else is in pretty desperate straits. (Some people do a bit better: soldiers, police, and bureaucrats who supplement their meager income by taking bribes).

The misery of the masses of Haitians is directly connected with the prevailing differences in standard of living and wealth.The wide gap between the rich and the poor has direct economic effects. In countries where there is a middle class—people who do not consume whatever little income they have—they can save a little bit of money to send children to school, to lend out to a relative who wants to start a little business, to purchase a small piece of land for growing vegetables. Here some people have opportunities for improving their condition. Where the gap between rich and poor is as stark as in Haiti, practically all productive resources are in the hands of the very rich. The poor have no chance for raising their incomes and, with it, reducing poverty.

In Haiti the gap between rich and poor is extreme. But the distance between the wealthy and the rest of us is growing steadily in the US and the fate of Haiti holds some important lessons for us.

Unequal distribution of resources and wealth affects poverty in other ways. In Haiti many people are malnourished and/or ill. Not only do they lack land and tools in order to create a decent living for their families but their physical energy is sapped by hunger and disease. Their intelligence and inventiveness cannot be put to use because people are debilitated by hunger.

But the main problem of large differences in economic condition is demonstrated by the Haitian government's problem in building weather proof shelters for the earthquake victims. The government cannot move without the approval of the very rich because, through their wealth, they control the political system. If the government depends for its existence on the very rich, it will serve them and not the majority of the population. The incredible maldistribution of wealth in Haiti is reflected in comparable political inequality. The government does not attend to the people without political power and that is clearly one of the causes of the misery of most of the people.

If the wealth of a nation is in the hands of a small minority, the rest of the population is not well cared for. There are no schools for many Haitian children. Large numbers of adults have no education, and thus have very limited possibilities for making a living, let alone improve the condition of their families or their village.

That neglect of the masses of Haitians, of course, produces constant political unrest. The rich and powerful elite could deal with that by improving the lot of the poor, that is by redistributing wealth. But it is cheaper to do so by harsh political repression. The Haitian elite has chosen that route. The result is constant turmoil barely controlled, much of the time, by a repressive and brutal government.

When political power is in the hands of a small group of super rich families, political decisions favor them at the expense of people who are not rich. In the 1950s an international development project, financed and built by the US, dammed up a major river to create a lake for electricity generation and irrigation. The electricity went to light up the houses of the rich; the irrigation benefits large farms downstream from the dam that are owned by multinational agribusiness. The profit from the agribusinesses move abroad to the foreign owners of the agribusinesses; much of it ends up in the US. (Some Americans live a little bit better at the expense of the Haitian poor.) Only the pittance earned by farm workers remains in Haiti. The lake itself drove many Haitian farmers off their fertile farmland. Their children were forced to move into the city to stitch soccer balls and catchers' mitts for American firms for a few pennies an hour. The rich got richer, and the poor did what they always do. The project to “help Haiti” only helped to further impoverish its population. By building that dam, the US supported the rich elite. This is only one instance of the bankers, agribusinesses and the government of the US making common cause with the rich and the powerful in Haiti.

Haitian poverty carries important lessons for the US. Inequality in the US has been increasing steadily since the 1970s at least. Wages and salaries of significant portions of the middle class have stagnated. Many well paying jobs have been exported abroad to be replaced by jobs that pay much less. At the other end, the pay of big executives, stock speculators, top athletes, and others have risen sharply. The results, according a recent study by two British researchers, have been increased drug use, obesity, violence, mental illness, teen age pregnancy and illiteracy. (See The Spirit Level by Kate Pickett and Richard Wilkinson).
As enormous wealth has become concentrated in fewer hands, more and more people are feeling desperate about their lives because they have no control over them. The power to ameliorate their situation is in the hand of a power elite who, clearly, do not care about the millions of people who work hard every day just to barely get by. The government bails out the banks so that they can make money again while unemployment is stuck at more than 10% nationwide and is much higher in many places. As the working poor and the middle class see not only that their situation is difficult but that they have no hope of improving it, they lash out in their families, against strangers, or most often against themselves. Stark economic inequality brings with it political inequality, which breeds anger and despair manifest in the daily list of murders and self-destructive behaviors.

The disappointment over the Obama presidency illustrates our impotence. The promise of “hope” and “change” have turned out to be hollow. Any slight attempt to reduce inequality, for instance, by making health care available to more people is stymied by lobbying of the insurance companies, the medical associations, and the drug companies. The outlook for reducing inequality, here as in Haiti is very poor. No wonder there is so much anger out there.